In a short paragraph (5–7 sentences), compare and contrast the two Christmas stories we read this week: "Gift of the Magi" and "The Heavenly Christmas Tree."

Do these stories present opposing or complementary perspectives on Christmas?
Do they share similar or different themes?
Use examples from the text to support your position. Please hurry

Answers

Answer 1

The summary of the book  "Gift of the Magi" shows the love between a couple who long to get each other a Christmas gift, but due to their lack of resources, they sell something valuable to get each other a gift.

The summary of the book "The Heavenly Christmas Tree." is the story of a six or seven-year-old boy and his sick mother who did not have the basic needs of life during Christmas time.

What is a Comparison?

This refers to the side-by-side analysis of two different entities to find the similarities and differences.

Hence, we can see that The summary of the book  "Gift of the Magi" shows the love between a couple who long to get each other a Christmas gift, but due to their lack of resources, they sell something valuable to get each other a gift.

The summary of the book "The Heavenly Christmas Tree." is the story of a six or seven-year-old boy and his sick mother who did not have the basic needs of life during Christmas time.

Read more about "Gift of the Magi" here:

https://brainly.com/question/27835330

#SPJ1


Related Questions

Ill give brainliest and 30 points
someone give me your honest opinion on this

Answers

1. You could use something along the lines of “I could have been a better listener during this group project I was doing a few months ago. I remember trying to be a leader and accidentally drowning out my teammates opinions” or it could be the opposite and along the lines of you not communicating on what you think should have been done and the outcome of the project was weak and could have been better with your idea.

2. Communicating in a way that others understand you. Something along the lines “if people are able to understand what I’m trying to get across then it will be easier for everyone. If they understand what I’m trying to say and we all help each other progress through it. Everyone will be successfull”

asking this cuz no one else had
Which events in the story show the development of the theme of predestination throughout the story? Select each correct answer. Select 2 correct answer(s) Question 3 options: The narrator unknowingly walks to the workshop of a monumental mason. The narrator works on a drawing for a long time over the course of a day. The gravestone mason greets the narrator with cheerfulness. Mr. Atkinson randomly engraves Mr. Withencroft's name and birthday.'

Answers

The  events in the story show the development of the theme of predestination throughout the story is that  Mr. Atkinson randomly engraves Mr. Withencroft's name and birthday.'

How is suspense created in August heat?

W.F. Harvey is known to be a man that has made  a suspense in his book titled the  “ August Heat “ though the use of the setting, as well as foreshadowing, and point of view.

Note that the use of the above is done so as to give an attention and to find out what will take place next.

Therefore, The  events in the story show the development of the theme of predestination throughout the story is that  Mr. Atkinson randomly engraves Mr. Withencroft's name and birthday.'

Learn more about predestination from

https://brainly.com/question/891274

#SPJ1

We might imagine that the experience of being hunted has
taught Rainsford his lesson about killing other animals. But
the fact that Rainsford sleeps in Zaroff's bed suggests
otherwise. Interpret the ending of this story and what it
says about Rainsford and humans more generally.

Answers

This is an extract from The Most Dangerous Game, a short story by Richard Connell

One would hope that Rainsford's tragic experiences had at least given him some animal empathy and a better understanding of what it's like to be a prey animal.

However, the text's evidence would seem to support the opposite. Although we can't be certain, it would seem that Rainsford killed General Zaroff since otherwise, how else would he be found sleeping so peacefully in his bed?

Is he turning into the next Zaroff by taking over his bed? After all, he could have tried to flee or even slept in his own bed.

Think about this Zaroff leaves his position to Rainsford when he passes away. Has Rainsford consented already? How can someone sleep so soundly if he regrets killing a human being?

After all, Zaroff had assured him that, if he triumphed, he might leave the island.

Learn more about The Most Dangerous Game here:

https://brainly.com/question/2386531

#SPJ9

Read the following sets of sentences and restructure them, utilizing the method expressed in the parentheses. (Be certain to apply punctuation where necessary.)
(3.) My grandfather raised his daughters the old-fashioned way, for he was born eighty years ago in Puerto Rico. (relative pronoun clause)

Answers

Answer:

My grandfather, who was born eighty years ago in Puerto Rico, raised his daughters the old-fashioned way.

Explanation:

who-stands in lieu of I, she, he, us, and they in sentences?

whose-shows ownership or connection.

whom-substitutes subject pronouns like I, She, and He.

which-are inanimate items and living creatures (typically non-defining clauses).

that-for both humans and other objects (typically defining clauses).

When writing a routine information or action-request message, whenever possible, focus on benefits to you, the writer.

True or False?

Answers

When writing a routine information or action-request message, whenever possible, focus on benefits to you, the writer is a true statement.

What is a routine request message?

A routine request is one that does not ask for confidential, impounded, or sealed material as well as been used to seeks information that is included in case files, dockets, as well as indexes, lists, or schedules.

Note that in the writing of a routine request, it is one that is often opened  by stating your specific request and this is one that tells what you want them to do for you.

Therefore, based on the above, When writing a routine information or action-request message, whenever possible, focus on benefits to you, the writer is a true statement.

Learn more about action message from

https://brainly.com/question/12170995
#SPJ1

Please answer the question In the picture, I will mark brainliest

Answers

Answer:

This is missing a lead i might not know if its true but it seemed right out of all the options

Explanation:

How is priyas mother different from American mothers

Answers

Answer:

Her mother, Ritu, learned to adapt Indian recipes for the more American tastes Priya and her sister had developed, dreaming up recipes

Explanation:

following paragraph and answer the question: Beth lay in bed unable to fall asleep. Her eyes darted around the dark room. The wind roared causing the tree branch her window with an ear piercing scream. Suddenly she heard something coming up the steps. Thump, thump, thump, it was getting closer. She tightly squeezed her t as the door slowly creaked open." What is the mood of this paragraph?
A. Scary
B. Happy
C. Depressing
D. Silly

Answers

I’d say it’s A.Scary the atmosphere of the room is more scary than depressed. Especially because the words “The wind roared causing the tree branch to scratch her window with a piercing scream.”

Choose the words that will complete the
analogy correctly.
ROBUST: STRONG ::

SICKLY: MAIMED

SICKLY: UNWELL

SICKLY ATHLETIC

SICKLY: WELL

Answers

The word that will complete the analogy correctly is sickly: unwell.

The most basic definition of an analogy is the comparison of two things that are otherwise dissimilar. An analogy is a comparison that is used to highlight a point or offer clarification. Analogies explain and illustrate by contrasting various ideas, each of which has a counterargument, moving from the known to the unknown. An analogy is a type of argument, whereas similes and metaphors are rhetorical devices. A metaphor is something, and a simile is like something, whereas an analogy explains how one thing is like another and aids in explaining them both. Analogies focus on various word connections. Learning them will strengthen, develop, and reinforce skills in vocabulary, detail-oriented, reading comprehension, synonyms, antonyms, homophones, deductive reasoning, and logic.

Learn more about analogy https://brainly.com/question/21962882

#SPJ1

Which sentence best summarize the day of Sarah's arrival in Sarah, Plain and Tall?

Answers

The  sentence that best summarize the day of Sarah's arrival in Sarah, Plain and Tall is option D) Papa meets Sarah at the train station and brings her home to meet Anna and Caleb. Sarah has gifts for the children and introduces the family to her cat.​

What is Sarah Plain and Tall's synopsis?

The story of a lonely family, including widower Jacob and his children Anna and Caleb, and Sarah, the woman from the east coast who responds to Jacob's newspaper post for a wife, is told in  Sarah's arrival in Sarah, Plain and Tall.

Note that Jacob reveals to his kids that he has been writing to Sarah, who resides in a coastal town.

Hence, The  sentence that best summarize the day of Sarah's arrival in Sarah, Plain and Tall is option D) Papa meets Sarah at the train station and brings her home to meet Anna and Caleb. Sarah has gifts for the children and introduces the family to her cat.​

Learn more about Sarah, Plain and Tall from

https://brainly.com/question/28289146
#SPJ1

Which sentences best summarize the day of Sarah's arrival in Sarah, Plain and Tall?

A) Caleb and Anna do their chores while they wait for Papa to return. When the children meet Sarah, they ask her whether she has brought the sea with her.

B) Caleb and Anna talk about what it will be like meeting Sarah. When she arrives, the children see that she looks exactly as she described herself in her letters.

C) Papa feeds and waters the horses before going into town. Sarah and Papa return to the house and Sarah compares the way the land rolls to the way the sea moves.

D) Papa meets Sarah at the train station and brings her home to meet Anna and Caleb. Sarah has gifts for the children and introduces the family to her cat.​

HELP. I NEED THIS QUICK!

Answers

The right answer is, Sometimes we can find the greatest treasures in our own yards.

The falling action of the story is the part of the story after the climax where the tension arising from the story's central conflict diminishes and the story approaches its conclusion. A setting is a physical and social context in which the action of a story takes place. The main elements of the setting are the time, place, and social environment that make up the characters.

In fiction, these issues are called conflicts. More specifically, conflict means frustration, compromised, or opposing desires. Basically when a character wants something but something else is getting in the way. Maybe the character wants something but can't get it. The antagonist is the most common type of external conflict. It should be clearly and broadly understood as a story of good versus evil in which the protagonist faces a distinct challenge.

Learn more about The antagonist here:-https://brainly.com/question/1420323

#SPJ9

The students have not completed their assessment yet. Choose action verb or linking verb

Answers

The given sentence: "The students have not completed their assessments yet." contains a linking verb as it connects the subject to the action that completes the sentence.

What is a Verb?

This refers to the part of speech that shows the action in a sentence

Hence, we can see that The given sentence: "The students have not completed their assessments yet." contains a linking verb as it connects the subject to the action that completes the sentence.

Read more about verbs here:

https://brainly.com/question/14584990

#SPJ1

In lines 24-37 what evidence does Wallace offer to support her idea that people are not always focused on doing " whatever [is] necessary to survive " in a crisis? Is the evidence relevant and sufficient? Explain

Answers

The evidence that Wallace decided to use is the anecdote that an explosion occurred while she was having drinks with friends at Grand Central Station.

Wallace said people had mixed reactions as he pushed through the crowd staring at the plume of smoke rising from the front of the station. Some people were crying and screaming on their cell phones, not doing the only thing that would increase everyone's chances of survival if they moved out of the area.

Wallace's evidence is relevant and sufficient because it portrays the crisis as accurately as possible, but it deviates significantly from what she claims. However, I was shocked and surprised by what happened in front of me. society sometimes judges people who survive more harshly than it should.

Learn more about Wallace here:-https://brainly.com/question/15363411

#SPJ9

What does the excerpt reveal about Well’s view of capitalism and class in the britain of his day

Answers

In The Time Machine, Wells theorized that the gap between the upper and working classes in the Victorian era would persist into the distant future, resulting in two distinct races of people.

The required details for Victorian era in given paragraph

The Victorian era of the United Kingdom and its Empire abroad covers Queen Victoria's 63-year reign (1837-1901). The monarch's function at this point was to reign rather than to rule. Victoria functioned as the country's symbolic leader.

The Industrial Revolution, authors Charles Dickens and Charles Darwin, the railway and shipping boom, significant scientific advancements, the first telephone and telegraph, and huge political and social transformation all occurred during the Victorian era.

To know about Victorian era in given link

https://brainly.com/question/1155331

#SPJ9

Phrases that employ a verb form are termed _________ phrases.

*verbal
*prepositional
*participial
*gerund

Answers

Answer:

verbal

Explanation:

What characteristics of family functioning during the colonial, slavery, and/or industrialization still occur today? How is “today’s family” different from the families of the past?

Answers

Over the years, the family functioning has  changed considerably. Divorce, remarriages have grown in number. Single-parent households are rising with a drop in fertility rate. Family dynamics have changed over the time.

How is “today’s family” different from the families of the past?

The family of past were regarded as a social unit, whereas the modern families have become individual in nature. In traditional family  all the members of a family lived at one  and they were bound together by a common residence.

During Colonialism , industrial revolution and slavery  made it difficult for stable and secure family formation. Enslaved people could not legally marry in any American colony. Also families were broken as the member were sold to different owners.

During the period of  Industrial Revolution, many families who were poor or had low income lower found themselves struggling to earn a living sufficient enough for their survival. They were forced to move to the growing industrial cities in search for work. Children were forced to work in harsh conditions to earn extra income.

To learn more about family functions

https://brainly.com/question/20049838

#SPJ1

I think I should indicate why I am here in Birmingham, since you have been influenced by the view which argues against "outsiders coming in." I have the honor of serving as president of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, an organization operating in every southern state, with headquarters in Atlanta, Georgia. We have some eighty five affiliated organizations across the South, and one of them is the Alabama Christian Movement for Human Rights. Frequently we share staff, educational and financial resources with our affiliates. Several months ago the affiliate here in Birmingham asked us to be on call to engage in a nonviolent direct action program if such were deemed necessary. We readily consented, and when the hour came we lived up to our promise. So I, along with several members of my staff, am here because I was invited here. I am here because I have organizational ties here. is this ethos, pathos, or logos

Answers

We can actually deduce here that the given statement from "Letter From Birmingham Jail" is ethos.

What is ethos?

Ethos is a rhetorical appeal that is used in persuasion by which a speaker or writer builds and establishes credibility and knowledge in the minds of the audience. In other words, ethos is used to make the audience to believe the speaker or writer as a result of the speaker's rich background or qualification or experience.

We see here that "Letter from Birmingham Jail" was actually written by Martin Luther King Jr.

It is known to have been written in order to speak against the injustices that the negroes where passing through.

Learn more about "Letter From Birmingham Jail" on https://brainly.com/question/25843788

#SPJ1

mica cowers her mouth when coughing in a crowded area: answer happy or sad

Answers

Answer: sad

Explanation: she is coughing in a crowded area meaning she is sick and spreading it

Which phrases best shows how the authors diction creates a bleak mood
Uncovering the truth
Images of black beasuty
Fix their hair problems
Face harsh realities

Answers

The phrase which shows how the author's diction creates a bleak mood is "face harsh realities".

The excerpt is from "Why Do Black Women Fear the Fro?” by Cheryl Thompson. Throughout the author's description of how a black woman faces struggles in her life trying to cope with society's expectations. As the woman sees all these expectations thrown at her she tries to change herself according to the ways people around her dictate, instead of accepting herself as beautiful as she is.

The bleak mood is a gleaming or depressing situation, here in this context as the black woman sees all those standards she is expected to meet and eventually her harsh realities such as struggling with a low-paying job and reduced opportunities in life come to view.

Learn more about Author's diction:

https://brainly.com/question/2141393

https://brainly.com/question/28283664

#SPJ9

Which of the following describes what good good writers are trying to achieve by varying the length of their sentences

Answers

Answer:

The answer is Short sentences are easier to read

Explanation:

Deep learning software is inspired by the structure of the brain's
neocortex, the grooved upper layer of the brain that's in charge of
complex mental functions like sensory perception, spatial reasoning, and
language. The neocortex makes up about three-fourths of the brain and is
itself made up of six layers. The layers contain ten to fourteen billion
neurons' which vary in shape, size, and density from layer to layer.
Deep learning software? simulates this layered structure with an
artificial neural network that enables computers to learn to solve
problems through examples. Artificial neural networks rely on big sets of
training data and powerful computers--both of which are becoming
increasingly available. In recent years, deep learning has been focused on
improving image and speech recognition software, and using the
technique for language translation is a logical progression.
1 specialized cells that transmit nerve impulses
2 programs and other operating information used by a computer. What is the author saying about how programmers designed the computer software? What is the author saying about how the programmers designed the computer software

Answers

The inference is that the author is trying to demonstrate how languages can be translated by computers.

What do you mean by inference ?

Remember that an inference is the conclusion that can be drawn from the provided information.

The implication is that the author is illustrating here how computers can be used to translate languages.

The author's use of the term "deep learning" as a basis for the evidence that was illustrated.

Learn more about inference

brainly.com/question/25280941

#SPJ9

Read the two excerpts from the text.
Excerpt 1:
(1)... "I have not begun it yet," he always said, "but I shall be at it every night once the winter sets in...."
Excerpt 2:
(44) Summer came, and then he said:
(45) "It is too hot to write books. Get me another bottle of iced soda-water. I'll tackle the book in the autu
How does the author create tension in these excerpts?
OA. by showing the seasons passing while the conflict remains between the characters
OB. by illustrating the increasing demands that the husband is making on his wife
OC. by suggesting that the two characters don't realize how quickly they are aging
OD. by revealing how infrequently the wife expresses her own needs and opinions

Answers

The author create tension in these excerpts A. by showing the seasons passing while the conflict remains between the characters.

What is tension in literature?

Consider tension as the thread that runs through the main story, the supporting plots, and the growth of the characters. The manifestation of tension comes from a suspenseful build-up that intensifies as your protagonist's circumstances alter.

Withholding information and posing important questions that stimulate readers' interest are two ways to create tension. Suspense is greatly influenced by character development; for instance, if a character's wish is not granted at the book's conclusion, the novel will not feel satisfying to the reader

In this case, the author create tension in these excerpts by showing the seasons passing while the conflict remains between the characters.

In conclusion, the correct option is A.

Learn more about tension on:

https://brainly.com/question/918617

#SPJ1

Explain Chris's reaction when it began to rain in
the Detrital Valley, creating flood waters that
eventually ruined his car.

Answers

Chris's reaction is to continue his journey and abandon the car, taking only a few belongings with him.

Why does he do this?Because he wants to let go of material possessions.Because he wants to abandon any relationship with capitalist society.Because he feels he won't need the car.

Chris decided to abandon all society and live in nature. He did this because of his strong dissatisfaction with capitalist society and the whole civilized environment around him.

For this reason, he abandoned all his activities, his family, and friends and leaves with his car to living in the forest. Along the way, his car was flooded and his reaction was to leave the car behind, just like all the other things that connected him to the consumerist and capitalist society.

This question is about the book "Into the Wild" and you can learn more about it at the link below:

https://brainly.com/question/23614363

#SPJ1

3. Page 472, Exposition: What is the reason for the complaints against Rebecca Nurse?

Answers

Answer:

Anne's jealousy of Rebecca's ability to have a large family.

Explanation:

Describe the 7 Articles of the Constitution. (1 paragraph)

Answers

The 7 Articles of the Constitution are the foundation of our country's government. They contain the basic rights and responsibilities that we as citizens have, as well as how our government is structured to operate. The Articles were written to ensure that everyone has a voice in our democracy, which is why each citizen has an equal right to vote.

When I saw my grandmother ordering gardening supplies online, it struck me that the days of brick-and-mortar shops might be doomed. Not that my grandmother is a dinosaur, mind you. She is a wizard with the remote, uses social media to stay in touch with her friends, and sends text messages with ease. However, she is certainly not of a generation that grew up with computers or the Internet.

Her purchase got me thinking about the early days of online shopping, when people were anxious about ordering merchandise from the Internet. What if the items never arrived? Was putting all my personal information online safe? Should I really disclose my credit card information to some unknown entity? Is this online company legitimate? And last but not least, who would buy something without seeing it first? But my grandmother’s transaction made it clear: online shopping has become as commonplace as brushing your teeth.

What is the cultural context of this passage?


The reading takes place in a past generation. The narrator is a grandmother who shares her thoughts about online shopping.


The reading takes place in a past generation. The narrator is a grandmother who shares her thoughts about online shopping.


The reading takes place in modern times. The narrator considers her beliefs about the cultural changes regarding shopping online.


The reading takes place in the early days of online shopping. The story is set in a doomed brick-and-mortar shop.

Answers

The cultural context of this passage is C. the reading takes place in modern times. The narrator considers her beliefs about the cultural changes regarding shopping online.

The cultural environment is related to the society where individualities are raised and how the culture affects geste. It incorporates values that are learned and stations that are participated among groups of people. It includes beliefs, meanings, customs, ideas, language, and norms. It requires understanding that cognition, provocation, emotion, and geste are shaped by individualities' artistic values and morals. The same gesture takes on different meanings in different artistic surrounds, and different artistic surrounds promote divergent normative responses to the same event. Cultural content Refers to the emblematic meaning, cultural dimension, and artistic values that appear from or express artistic individualities.

Learn more about cultural context here: https://brainly.com/question/25010777

#SPJ1

Write about a pet you know that gets into trouble, use this for of this word: stay, obey, claim, they, cane, face, break, ache, clay, today

Answers

The suitable sentence should be - Today harry's dog has gone out of control and eventually fell into a pile of clay and broke his face causing them an ache, in order to make them stay calm they were shown a cane.

How to form sentences regarding pets?

First what one shall do is choose as to about which pet one is going to write about. The pet can be of one's own or from some neighborhood or relatives.

Upon choosing the right pet about who you know enough, recall the event where they fell into some trouble and caused a fiasco and carefully adjust the words in the sentence to provide the information about the event.

To read more about, pets, refer to - https://brainly.com/question/28517632

#SPJ1

how did Macedonia rise to power in the 300s BC, according to world history ?

Answers

Answer: subduing all of Macedonia's neighbors

Explanation: Archelaus (413-399 BC) turns Macedonia into an economic power and reorganizes the Macedonian army. [359-336 BC] Philip II (359-336 BC) raises Macedonia into the greatest European Power after subduing all of Macedonia's neighbors - Illyrians, Thracians, and Greeks.

Why do French doctors dislike Dr Mesmer?

Answers

Answer:

Mesmer tricks their patients into believing in fake treatments.

Explanation:


A critical component of student success which allows students to work towards challenges and is
associated with tenacity and persistence is sometimes referred to as:
O Grit
O Stamina
O Emotional Intelligence
O Social-Emotional Awareness

Answers

An important component of student success that enables students to work on problem-solving and is associated with perseverance and perseverance is sometimes referred to as socio-emotional awareness.

Success is the state or condition of meeting a certain range of expectations. This can be seen as the opposite of failure. Success criteria are context-dependent and may refer to specific observers or belief systems.

Success brings confidence, security, euphoria, opportunities to contribute at a higher level, hope and leadership. Without success, you, your group, your company, your goals, your dreams, and even your entire civilization don't exist. Most people attribute success to a successful career, wealth, and peer respect. But do not miss the goal that will contribute to a happier life. Relationship priorities, physical health, safety, helping others, and creative expression were found to promote happiness.

Learn more about success here: https://brainly.com/question/24959987

#SPJ9

Other Questions
Which items would you take on a trip? Check all thatapply. Poems (poetry)by Emily DickinsonMuch Madness Is Divinest SenseMuch Madness is divinest SenseWe Grow Accustomed to the Dark.. what do you think the title of the poem means HELP PLEASE Graph the point (-2,3) and 3 more points using a slope of -1/2 . a boat costs x dollars, and this cost is to be shared equally by a group of people. in terms of x, how many dollars less will each person contribute if there are 4 people in the group instead of 3 during the covid-19 pandemic, a local wine and spirits retailer faced changes in store hours, supply of and demand for its products, sanitizing protocols, and converting to drive-through, curbside, or delivery services only. during this time, the store manager, owen, shared daily updates with employees by e-mail and on posted announcements. owen also updated the store's website and social media pages regularly. in this scenario, owen was playing the role. what is solar system Which part of a cell synthesises proteins? The number of cars a salesman sold each month for a two year period are represented by the box and whisker plot below. Which of the following statements is most likely to be true?In approximately 50% of the months he sold less than 9 cars.In approximately 25% of the months he sold less than 12 cars.In approximately 75% of the months he sold more than 12 cars.In approximately 25% of the months he sold less than 9 cars. The earth on the turtles back Ross is buying pecans and cashews at the supermarket. There is a proportional relationship between the weight of the nuts and the cost.This table shows the cost of pecans:PecansWeight (pounds)Cost0.5$51.5$154$40This equation describes the cost of cashews, where y represents the cost in dollars and x represents the weight in pounds:y=9.35xWhich nuts have a higher unit price?How much more do those nuts cost?$ more per pound an audit identifies poor coding, documentation, and billing practices so that additional training and education can occur and procedures can be adjusted. For what values of x is x^3+18x^2+92x+120=0 a true statement. 5m + n = 10 Solve for m what are your family rules? when liquid water loses energy, a change in state or chemical identity occurs. This is an example of a chemical or physical change? a conflict will exist between the npv and irr methods, when used to evaluate two equally risky but mutually exclusive projects, if the projects' cost of capital is less than the rate at which the projects' npv profiles cross. true false yt/x=m Solve for 'y'. In a classroom, 14 children have a dog as a pet, 11 children have cats and 3 who have both. If 24 children don't have either a cat of a dog, how many children are in the classroom. The two lines graphed below are not parallel. How many solutions are there tothe system of equations?A. TwoB. OneC. ZeroD. Infinitely many Show Your WorkThe steps a student took to solve an equation are shown below.2(x+4)= 6(x-2)Step 1:Step 2:Step 3:Step 4:-2x-8=6x-12-8=4x-124 = 4xx = 1What error did the student make and what is the correct valueof x?